Revival of the Grand Palais

The falling rivet that saved the Grand Palais
Watch out!
A falling rivet in 1993 was the wake up call that things were not exactly right within and beneath the Grand Palais.

What happened during the past 12 years while the Grand Palais was closed to the public and why for the next year it will be shrouded and framed by scaffolding is a continuing story. But there is hope because it is no longer sliding into the banks of the Seine river.

Panel translations inside the Grand Palais
When you enter this edifice during the coming two years for varied events you will most likely see several panels (in French) and photos. The first you notice touches on the cost of the renovations (between 2002 and 2007), once inside panels explain the history and events that led up to the current situation, and another panel sums up the edifice as a modern building in fewer words.

The translations are provided for your information on another page, along with photos also shown on these panels.

The doors once again open
One night in January 2006, while walking along the Champs Elysées, the nave of the Grand Palais was lit in reds, lavenders, yellows, greens, etc. Under the big top’s 15,000 square meters (161,458 square feet) was an amusement park and circus!

I visited the interior the next day and recorded the images within this immense cavern filled with amusement rides including two Ferris wheels, bumper cars, and was filled with the wafts of air filled with the scent of waffles and cotton candy.

During 2005, the doors of the Grand Palais were opened for special occasions such as “les Journées du Patrimoine” and a concert. The public could see just how far this once “beached whale” had come.

My last memory of the interior was of dusty, dirty greenhouse-type windows and dingy beams during a design show.

That would be my last Grand Palais exhibition. The Lartique exhibit in 1993 that I procrastinated in
attending would be the last exhibition of any kind under the big top until 2005.

Triumphant at last
In the end a refined beauty awaits the public instead of a rubble heap. Six years and two phases of work will bring her back to full triumphant glory (2002 – 2007). I did read in the magazine NouvelObs that a third phase for security enhancement may once again temporarily close the doors in 2008.

One could say that the quadrigas that top the north and south points of the palace are appropriate. The four-horse chariots harnessed and driven by the maiden who keeps them from galloping away lives up to its originally-intended symbolism of triumph and victory..

The Grand Palais was headed for demolition. Procrastination took place among decision makers. This delay may have saved the Grand Palais.

The Grand Palais has survived two world wars, multiple changes in architectural styles and the abuse of exhibitions when hanging, heavy objects weakened its frame.

Art exhibits since 1993
The Grand Palais, built between 1897 and 1900, has always been devoted to the arts. From the beginning it was a “monument consecrated by the Republic to the glory of French art” (inscription on the front of the Grand Palais).

Even during its closure of the grand nef the Grand Palais has continued exhibiting art in two other locales. My imagery of the one is of cardboard cubicles.

The other is a series of galleries initiated in 1964 by André Malraux, the Culture minister. These galleries were intended to present prestigious, temporary, international art exhibitions.

As you continue to visit the other pages on this story, you will see that art takes many forms under this glass roof (The Paris home show (Foire de Paris), automobile show (Salon de l’Auto – 1908), air show (Salon de l’aéronautique), childrens’ fair (Salon de l’enfance) or the home appliance fair (le Salon des arts ménagers) and everyone of them required construction of spectacular interiors and equestrian competitions (Concours hippique au Grand Palais, 1938-1939.)

Be sure to visit the Grand Palais, if not for a special event, during the Heritage Days (Journées du Patrimoine) September or White Nights (Nuits Blanche) in October). Between September and the end of October 2005, 500,000 came to admire this renewed giant of glass and iron –le NouvelObs-Bernard Géniès.

Watch out!
A falling rivet in 1993 was the wake up call that things were not exactly right within and beneath the Grand Palais.

The translations are provided for your information on another page, along with photos also shown on these panels.

My last memory of the interior was of dusty, dirty greenhouse-type windows and dingy beams during a design show.

That would be my last Grand Palais exhibition. The Lartique exhibit in 1993 that I procrastinated in
attending would be the last exhibition of any kind under the big top until 2005.

The Grand Palais was headed for demolition. Procrastination took place among decision makers. This delay may have saved the Grand Palais.

The Grand Palais has survived two world wars, multiple changes in architectural styles and the abuse of exhibitions when hanging, heavy objects weakened its frame.

Even during its closure of the grand nef the Grand Palais has continued exhibiting art in two other locales. My imagery of the one is of cardboard cubicles.

The other is a series of galleries initiated in 1964 by André Malraux, the Culture minister. These galleries were intended to present prestigious, temporary, international art exhibitions.

History of events at the Grand Palais
Translation of panels and photographs inside the Grand Palais during exhibitions 2005-2006:
Beautifully cradled by its colossal white stone columns and proudly displaying its glass ceiling under the sun and under the rain, the Grand Palais is one of the most familiar Parisian landmarks.

People even started to think it was immortal. The fall of a rivet from the glass ceiling in 1993, however, showed that this was not the case. This masterpiece erected during World’s Fair of 1900 (l’Exposition Universelle de 1900) was falling apart. The great exhibition hall (grand nef) had to be closed to the public while emergency stairs were hastily built for the exhibition areas.

Just as Newton’s apple produced the laws of gravity; the fateful rivet started a small revolution. Restoration was inevitable.

Aside from the decision process of the authorities (1993 to 2002) and given the huge sums involved, these decision makers should be excused for their slow response. There were some who wanted to demolish the Grand Palais.

Today, as the restoration work continues, the general public can once again lift their eyes safely towards to the quadrigas – the harnessed furious horses clinging to façade.

Georges Récipon, the sculptor, designed the two quadrigas. On the south side towards the River Seine is the sculpture representing harmony triumphing over disorder (L’Harmonie triumphant de la discorde); and on the north side immortality outliving time (L’Immortalité devançant le temps). What better symbol could you dream of to initiate the restoration of the monument under favorable conditions?

How did we get to the edge of this abyss? How did we get to the near destruction of the most beautiful exhibition palace in the world?

A criticized building
The building started to resemble one of those beached whales – pathetic, better to be sliced up than attempt to put it afloat. Its restoration had become a colossal financial burden for the government.

The Grand Palais, property of the Republic, was destined for sports, agricultural and cultural events; the Petit Palais was transformed into the museum of Beaux Arts de la Ville de Paris after the closure of l’Exposition Universelle of 1900. Even though its architecture had been criticized during its construction, the Grand Palais would be like the Petit Palais across the street – destined to endure in comparison to the temporary constructions on the esplanade of the Invalides and along the shore of the Seine. And well built they were.

The idea was to erect a real palace of the fine arts. A few years after the demolition of the Tuilleries Palace, the royal residence and then an Imperial residence (between Louis XVI to Napoléon III), the Republic wanted to show to the world that it was capable of building magnificent monuments.

Until then the World Fairs had never rendered any first rate monuments for posterity except for the Eiffel Tower, finished in 1889, and much criticized at the time. As to others, the French novelist, Huysmans, compared the Palace of the Trocadero, built in 1878, to the legs of a bloated woman because of its enormous paunch topped by two thin pinnacles.

The Palais de l’Industrie, built on the 1855 on the Champs-Elysées, had become unfashionable; its main draw back being to hide the Invalides. It was, therefore, destroyed.

In 1900 the objective was to do something much better. The future Grand Palais was part of an ambitious urban project. Construction included a new large avenue – Avenue Nicholas II which would become Avenue Winston Churchill, and a bridge, Alexandre III in the same axis as the prestigious Hôtel des Invalides.

This was to be a masterful piece, a perfect opus. But like all great projects, this one stirred up massive criticism. Famous writers, although radically opposed in their political views such Anatole France and Maurice Barres, argued for Nancy (they were both from the Lorraine region) as the venue for the l’Exposition Universelle. Others were shocked that one of the most beautiful urban promenades in the world would be altered. And other people were militant for keeping the Palace de l’Industrie….

A petition of artists, among who were Rodin, Falguiere, Cavalille-Coll and Eugène Carriere expressed confidence in the future….

Opposition was strong in the Chamber of Deputies .The government project of introducing income taxes did not help the debate and at end of the day, partisans (supporters) of the Grand Palais won the battle.

Equestrian competitions and expositions
On the 22 April 1896, a law was passed announcing a competition for the construction of the Grand Palais in the Journal Officiel.

Consisting of exposition galleries with a surface of more 40,000 square meters, (430,556 sq. ft.), the Grand Palais would present two art exhibits during the Exposition of 1900 — one, a retrospective, the “Centennale”, and the other contemporary art. After that it would be dedicated to annual exhibits of the Beaux Arts, which were the pinnacle of the artistic life in Paris, and to other events such as equestrian, agricultural and flower events.

The building would house a range of amenities such as a bar, a buffet, various general administrative offices, a police station, and a concert hall, as well as saddle makers, stables and horse feed stores.

Forty nine different architecture projects were submitted. Under the guidance of Charles Garnier the jury indicated that all projects showed great talent but none of them were up to the task. It was therefore decided that the most talented architects would submit new proposals. The solid classical schooling of Louis Louvet, 1860-1936, a prize-winning architect, Henri Deglane 1855-1931, Albert Thomas 1847-1907 and Charles Girault 1851-1932, distinguished architects and Grand Prix de Rome laureates, guaranteed a certain level of quality.

Girault was chosen to build the Petit Palais and to supervise the construction of the Grand Palais. Three men were necessary to build it and a fourth one was needed to put all of their ideas and drawings together.

Then there was the slowness of the administration of the French Planning office of the exposition who reported directly to the minister of commerce and who nominated the assistants to the architects.

Fifty people worked with the architects, Deglane, Louvet and Thomas. The 23 assistants of Girault were also involved in the construction site. In addition, there were a number of engineers involved in the construction of the metallic structure.

Paradoxically, it was probably this heavy hierarchy and tedious decision making which saved the monument during a less-than popular period after the First World War. A more extravagant and daring monument would probably not have survived the 1930s. The way it was built with a classical metallic structure and in a discreet Art Nouveau style, the Grand Palais survived two world wars and architectural style changes.

Saved from sinking
Nevertheless, this great vessel was gradually sinking into the ground. The great flooding of the Seine in 1910 was a cause of alarm in a similar way to Venice. The foundation of the Grand Palais was built on old oak pilings pounded into the ground. The gradual decrease in the ground water level caused the stakes to rot and the building to lean toward the south. The foundation of the building sank about 15 cm (5.9 in.).

Just as the tiny pea kept the Princess awake in the story of the Princess and the Pea, this miniscule settling had great consequences.

By leaning toward the Seine, the structure of this enormous vessel was weakened and could no longer be held together. In addition, the pinnacle on top of the dome had a leak rusting the metallic frame of the roof.

This was made worse by different structures put in place during exhibits such as the prestigious car show weakening the frame. Like the Titanic, the Grand Palais was slowly sinking while its metal frame was being twisted.

The final restoration and consolidation of the building began in 2002 under the supervision of France’s public building and national palaces (Bâtiments civils et Palais nationaux). The first phase of the work, which was to consolidate the foundation of the building, was completed in 2004. New deeper foundations were built in order to secure the building to the limestone layer.

Two new levels of underground basement surface were created. The metal framework was stripped, repaired and repainted in their original color, pale Reseda green. The roof windows which had already been replaced in the 1960s were entirely replaced, primarily for security reasons. The glass used at the time was not strong enough to withhold a worker falling on it. A new method was found to reconstitute the initial support of the structure and maintain its rhythm. The result is astonishing.

There is once again a graphic harmony between the transparent glass and the support of the metallic structure. Now the glass ceiling panels seem to emit singing sounds generated by small changes in the outside temperature. As for the dome it was elevated about one-inch thanks to hydraulic jacks to allow the replacement of broken parts.

Renovation costs of the Grand Palais
This panel appeared on the exterior of the Grand Palais explaining briefly the costs of the renovations of the Grand Palais:

In June 1993, a rivet came loose on the metal frame of the nave, about 35 meters (114 feet) causing the closing in November of the Grand Palais.

The government decided that the time had come to make the necessary renovations of this exhibition building, classified on November 6, 2000 as a historical monument.

The work would be accomplished in two phases:

The first phase (2002 – 2004) treated the most urgent points: foundations of the nave, complete repairs to the metal frame of the nave and the elements related to the roof, ceiling and glass; and restoration of the Récipon quadrigas (horses pulling the chariot).

The second phase (2005 – 2007) treats the façade restoration, the stucco ceilings, sculptures in stone and metal, ceramic and mosaic decorations and interior components, wrought iron decorations, as well as completing work on the foundations.

The work is budgeted for 101 million euros (120 million dollars) – 72,3 million euros for the first phase and 29,06 million euros for the second phase.

le salon de l’Automobile de 1908 (L.L./Roger-Viollet)

Les quadriges de Récipon (photo Fr3)

Grand Palais Story (.pdf document from my old Web site)

Grand Palais History (.pdf document from my old Web site)